Trade Marks and Passing Off: Tubzee Ltd. v Saffron Foods Ltd.

Because  it was tried by John Behrens in Leeds I have blogged Tubzee Ltd v Saffron Foods Ltd. [2008] EWHC B15 in my IP Yorkshire blog. This was a trade mark infirngement and passing off case between two Halifax kulfi makers.  There is not much law in it but it has a couple of points of interest as I say in my post.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Copyright in Photographs: Temple Island Collections and Creation Records

Image
In our very first NIPC newsletter which we published in June 1997 I wrote a case note on Mr. Justice Lloyd's decision in  Creation Records Ltd. and Others v News Group Newspapers Ltd   [1997] EMLR 444, [1997] EWHC Ch 370, (1997) 16 Tr LR 544. In that case Mr. Noel Gallagher of Oasis and others applied for an interlocutory injunction to restrain The Sun from offering for sale and selling a poster of Oasis that featured a photo of an elaborate set that included a white Rolls Royce in a country club swimming pool. The Sun's photograph was very similar to the photograph that appeared on an Oasis album cover. The similarity arose because The Sun's photographer shot the same scene at roughly the same time and from the same angle as Mr. Gallagher's photographer but he did not reproduce any part of Oasis's print or negative. The learned judge held that the plaintiffs had no arguable case for infringement of copyright though he accepted that they had an arguable case for br...
Read more

Trade Marks - Alice Ltd v Photogram Ltd and others

Image
Author  John Tenniel  Source Alice in Wonderland .  Penguin Books Licence Copyright expired Jane Lambert Intellectual Property Enterprise Court (Her Honor Judge Melissa Clarke  Alice Ltd v Photogram Ltd and other s [2024] EWHC 3256 (IPEC) (17 Dec 2024) This was an action for the infringement of UK trade mark UK00003362772 and a counterclaim for the revocation of the mark under s.46 (1) of the Trade Marks Act 1994.  The mark was the word ALICE registered for goods in class 9 and services in class 37.  Infringement was admitted subject to the validity of the registration.  The case turned on whether the mark had been put to genuine use in the first 5 years after registration or at any time since.  The action and counterclaim came on before Her Honour Judge Melissa Clarke on 24 Oct 2024. By para [101] of her judgment in  Alice Ltd v Photogram Ltd and other s [2024] EWHC 3256 (IPEC) which she handed down on 17 Dec 2024, the learned judge dismiss...
Read more

Inquiries as to Damages in the Intellectual Property Enterprise Court: Henderson v All Around the World Recordings Ltd.

Image
Money Photo Wikipedia I last discussed this litigation in  Success Fees and ATE Premiums in the Patents County Court: Henderson v All Around the World Recordings Ltd   4 May 2013. I set out the basic facts in my case note: "This was an action for infringement of a performer's rights which Judge Birss QC (as he then was) decided in Henderson v All Around the World Recordings Ltd and Another [2013] EWPCC 7 (13 Feb 2013)....... She had not been entirely successful and the costs of an unsuccessful copyright claim and half the costs of an application were awarded against her but she had succeeded overall." The claimant had entered a conditional fee agreement with specialist solicitors and counsel because it was the only way she could bring this litigation. Her total costs and disbursements including success fees and after-the-event premiums would have been £232,676.20 had they been allowed but Judge Birss QC (as he then was) awarded her only...
Read more